Shop Page Six editors’ all-time favorite lipsticks, from MAC to Tarte

Here at Page Six, we know which beauty buys are actually worth shopping — and which are just lip service.

In addition to rounding up celebrities’ favorite pout products, we’ve personally put countless lipsticks to the test over the years (with only a handful scoring permanent places in our beauty routines).

Below, shop staffers’ all-time favorites, from Taylor Swift’s signature red to nude hues that never go out of style.

“It took me ages to secure my first tube of this Taylor Swift-approved red, since it was sold out for literal years — but it was definitely worth the wait, and has been my holy grail ever since. I’d always avoided matte liquid lipsticks since they’re often drying, but not this one; it feels so lightweight and comfortable that I often forget I’m wearing it. It’s also the longest-lasting red lipstick I’ve ever tried, and the tapered teardrop applicator makes it easy to draw on the perfect pout. The color payoff is out of this world, and once you give it a few seconds to dry down, it’ll stay put for hours and hours.” — Elana Fishman, Style & Shopping Director

“Yet another Taylor Swift favorite (sensing a pattern here?), this warm cinnamon shade is my go-to for days when I’m not feeling a bold red lip. It’s so easy to wear and a total compliment magnet.” — Elana Fishman, Style & Shopping Director

“I’ve been wearing this lipstick for almost a year now — and last week, I learned that Martha Stewart and her amazing makeup artist, Daisy Toye, also buy it in bulk. I can totally see why they’re fans; it’s such a chic, understated nude hue that goes with practically any makeup look. I’ve tried plenty of similar shades, but keep coming back to MAC.” — Hannah Southwick, Associate Commerce Editor

“Sure, Pillow Talk gets all the glory — but have you seen its sister shade? It’s the prettiest flush of warm berry that, to me, is truly an ‘my lips but better’ color that always works. It’s softly seductive, and also has the smoothest velvet finish that’s lovely to wear.” — Erica Radol, Commerce Reporter

“I recommend the Sephora-brand lip stains to everyone; they’re not super matte and don’t dry your lips out, but still have incredible pigment and longevity. Marvelous Mauve is the perfect cool-toned purpley pink that goes with every look.” — Alexandra D’Aluisio, Senior Director of Content Strategy

“I usually stick to lip liner, but I do love this liquid lipstick. Its texture is creamy, it dries quickly and it really stays put throughout the day. I always receive compliments on it.” — Holly J Coley, Deputy Commerce Editor

“I wear this when I want to feel like a walking mermaid. It’s pearlescent (hence the name), but still provides a beautiful mauve-y swath of color that lip gloss just can’t deliver. Best worn going out on the town, or for making a statement.” — Georgie Olmeda, Commerce Partnerships Manager

“This pillowy, creamy formula does not cake or wrinkle; it feels like wearing an heirloom lipstick. The luxurious packaging takes it to the next level, but the product itself is a dream.” — Michelle Moezam, Senior Commerce Social Media Manager

“I’ve gotten so many compliments every time I wear this lipstick (and shared the name with so many friends). While I could write 1,000 words on why MAC should never discontinue this distinctive hue, I’ll keep it brief: This is my favorite lipstick of all time (and as a beauty writer, I’ve tried a lot). The subtle shimmer is just enough for an everyday look, without the stickiness of a gloss.” — Hannah Southwick, Associate Commerce Editor

“It’s the perfect shade, and the plumper addition makes my pout feel fuller. It’s not sticky, easy to apply and has a long-lasting wear. I can’t wait to buy it in more shades!” — Tori Schneebaum, Photo Director

“Black Honey is a perfect cross between a lipstick and a balm. It’s so hydrating, while still being decently pigmented. It also doesn’t taste like anything (to me), which I appreciate as someone who can gag at the slightest fake fruit or sweet flavor of some lipsticks. If I’m not wearing makeup that day, I’ll still always put on Black Honey because I know it will make me look a little more put together, but not in an aggressive way.”  — Georgie Olmeda, Commerce Partnerships Manager

“Lately I can’t stop swiping on L’Oréal Paris’ Colour Riche Intense Volume Matte Lipstick in the red-carpet-staple color Worth It. It’s a little brighter, weightless and long-lasting yet non-drying. It also smells wonderful — and you can often find it for under $10.” — Erica Radol, Commerce Writer/Reporter

“I literally just bought this in an attempt to replace my go-to MAC lipstick in Twist. Twist was also my tried and true, but I’ve wanted a softer, glossier option — and I found it with this color. It’s like my lips but better, and it goes on like butter. It’s also the best color to go with every single outfit, which is a must when you want to make the most of the summer in New York City.” — Sophia Caraballo, Associate Editor

“In my younger days, my go-to lipstick was always the classic MAC Ruby Woo. But as I’ve gotten older (and beauty trends have changed), I’ve started straying from a dry matte formula in favor of one with a little more hydration and a satin finish. This Vermillion color is red enough to make an impact, but it’s buildable and feels comfortable all day long.” — Melissa Minton, Style Senior Editor

“MAC’s Ruby Woo is a cult classic for a reason: The bestselling blue-red shade looks fabulous on pretty much everyone. For proof, look no further than the famous women who wear it: Rihanna, Janet Jackson, Angelina Jolie and Dita Von Teese are just a few. Paired with the matching MAC lip liner, it also happens to be one of the longest-lasting reds I’ve ever tried; I wore it to my birthday party this year, and it held up against a cheeseburger, cake and (too many) cocktails. Pro tip: Make sure you exfoliate your lips and prep with a good balm before slicking on this super-matte color.” — Elana Fishman, Style & Shopping Director

“Velvet Teddy is one of those classic colors that was revamped with shea butter, cocoa butter, and coconut oil to keep it matte yet moisturizing. I love the shade because it’s a neutral nude with a hint of pink, yet not so pale it erases lips. It looks beautiful with a smoky eye or minimal makeup, so I’m always reaching for it.” — Erica Radol, Commerce Reporter

“What could be a more perfect nude shade than one named after supermodel Christy Turlington? Pat McGrath’s formulations are some of the best in the biz in all categories, lipstick being no exception.” — Melissa Minton, Style Senior Editor

“I started using the Tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Balm before it went viral on TikTok and have been a fan ever since. I have this product in almost every color, but Hibiscus is my favorite because it’s the perfect everyday glossy nude.” — Alexandra D’Aluisio, Senior Director of Content Strategy

“Truthfully, I bought this lipstick during a college trip to Paris because I wanted to get something from the Dior store and this was all I could afford. But it ended up becoming a staple in my makeup bag. I’m not a huge lipstick girl (more of a liner and gloss gal), but this one is smooth, non drying, long-lasting and super pigmented.” — Brooke Matalon, New York Post Social Media Editor

Why Trust Page Six Style Shopping

This article was written by Hannah Southwick, Commerce Associate Editor for Page Six. Hannah spies deals on actually affordable celebrity-worn styles, puts celebrities’ brands to the test and finds the beauty products that keep stars red carpet-ready. She consults stylists and industry pros — including celebs themselves — for firsthand product recommendations, trend predictions and more. In addition to writing for Page Six since 2020, her work has been featured in USA Today and Parade.